droog magazine
HOME   

December 1, 2020 - Droog Magazine periodical for investigative journalism

The Hitler Forgery Industry

to Hitler Forgery Industry main page - to Droog Magazine

2015  | Global annual turnover |

Auctions |  Certificates of Authenticity


The strange business of selling fakes, forgeries and other concoctions attributed to Adolf Hitler (1889-1945) and other Nazi criminals.

The annual global turnover

"Naturally, exact figures are hard to come by, but the market’s annual global turnover is estimated to be in excess of £30m." [= €35 /$39 million] - Guardian, June 24, 2015.


"Despite the trade of Nazi antiquities being banned or strictly regulated in many countries, the market’s annual global turnover is expected to be in excess of $47 million." [= €42 / £36 million] - New York Post, June 27, 2015.

Alex Preston. The man who sleeps in Hitler's bed. [Article on Kevin Wheatcroft ]. The Guardian, London, June 24, 2015.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jun/24/the-man-who-sleeps-in-hitlers-bed

Copy of this article, with higher estimation of the turnover:

Alex Preston. This man owns the largest collection of Nazi artifacts. The New York Post, New York, June 27, 2015.
https://nypost.com/2015/06/27/meet-the-man-who-owns-the-worlds-largest-nazi-collection/


Origin of the estimation

The estimation originates via The Hitler Virus, a book from the American journalist Peter Wyden (1923-1998) from Stern Magazine, October, 1984. Wyden: "The Stern writers participated in one of the many auctions of "militaria" that have kept galleries flush with a business said to be grossing $40 million a year."

With inflation correction this amount would be equal to $127.3 million / £97.3 million / € 114.17 million anno 2019.

Yet, the prices and numbers of Nazi militaria items have only risen since 1984. This would logically mean that the annual turnover in 2019/2020 is much higher than was estimated before.

Peter Wyden. The Hitler Virus. The insidious legacy of Adolf Hitler. Arcade Publishing, New York, 1998. Reprint 2011.
Valuta rates October 2, 1984. Nederlands Dagblad, 02-10-1984.
https://resolver.kb.nl/resolve?urn=ddd:010628280:mpeg21:a0143
Calculation inflation correction. Waarde van de gulden/euro. [Value of the guilder/euro]. International Institute for Social History, Amsterdam, 06-01-2020.
http://www.iisg.nl/hpw/calculate-nl.php.




Auctions

2015 - 'Hitler' still life with Morgenstern stamp print



2015 - 'Hitler' with 'Morgenstern'-seal in USA

On March 26, 2015 auction house Nate D. Sanders in Los Angeles was about to auction a watercolor allegedly painted by Hitler, start price $ 30,000. Hitler would have made this work in 1912. Already in 1936 the Viennese police established that Hitler never painted still lifes  - which make this work a very silly fake.



Shortly before the auction this work was withdrawn. No reason was given.
On the back side of this work a S. Morgenstern stamp print was to be found, similar to the one depicted in Price (1983). Which means this fake is  one way or another connected to the Austrian art swindler Peter Jahn (1904-1990).


Left the alleged Morgenstern stamp print in Price; right the stamp print on the back of the 2015 "Hitler". They are made with the same stamp. 

We haven't traced a CoA issued by Peter Jahn to this work yet.

Statement by Jakob Altenberg. Oberpolizeirat Dr. Spring. Bundes Polizeidirektion Wien, Sicherheitsbureau, s.B. 17105/36, November-December 1936. NSDAP Hauptarchiv NS 26/2599; Bundesarchiv Berlin.

Ginger Adams Otis. Adolf Hitler’s painting of flowers goes on auction block New York Daily News, 23-03-2015.
http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/adolf-hitler-painting-flowers-auction-block-article-1.2159511
David Ng. Purported Adolf Hitler watercolor painting to be sold at auction. Los Angeles Times, 24-03-2015.

http://www.latimes.com/entertainment/arts/culture/la-et-cm-adolf-hitler-painting-auction-20150324-story.html
Hitler Flower Painting Could Exceed $30,000 At Auction. Artlyst.com, 25-03-2015
http://www.artlyst.com/news/hitler-flower-painting-could-exceed-30000-at-auction/
Danielle Haynes. LA auction house withdraws watercolor said to be by Hitler. UPI, 25-03-2015.
https://www.upi.com/Top_News/US/2015/03/25/LA-auction-house-withdraws-watercolor-said-to-be-by-Hitler/2991427321086/
Lot 8, veiling 26 maart 2015. Veilinghuis Nate D. Sanders (via Internet Archive)
https://web.archive.org/web/20150317233642/http://natedsanders.com:80/Adolf
_Hitler_Watercolor_Painting____During_His_Yea-LOT35911.aspx


2015 - 'Hitler' in Malaga

Op 28 maart 2015 wordt in het Spaanse Malaga bij 'International Autograph Auctions Europe, S.L.' een 'Hitler' geveild. Met dit verkoop-praatje:

"An original 10.5 x 14 watercolour painting, purported to be by Adolf Hitler, unsigned, the image depicting a clock tower, with various trees in the foreground. Annotated in contemporary pencil to the verso, in German, Stift bei Wels 18 Februar 1921 Adolf Hitler, indicating that the subject of the painting is the Wels Abbey in Austria." (...)

"Provenance: According to information supplied by the vendor, all of which is documented in various newspaper articles (copies of which are included with the lot) the present painting was gifted by Hitler to Herman Goering. It was later to come into the possession of former Luftwaffe pilot Karol Bachraty (father of the vendor) following his escape from a Russian Concentration Camp in 1945. Bachraty made his way to Italy, accompanied by other Third Reich officers. Bachraty was to spend the rest of his life in Chile where he encountered other former officers and together they formed a small association. Bachraty was elected with the chief responsibility of taking care of the paintings, some of which the colleagues intended to sell in order to fund a care home for former officers."

Een zoektocht naar 'Karol Bachraty' leidt naar een Spaanstalig blogstuk uit 2005, waar een hoogst onwaarschijnlijk verhaal wordt opgehangen over de Tsjechische piloot 'Karol Anton Bachraty Von Walzer' die met nog eens duizend andere Tsjechische piloten zou zijn overgelopen naar de Luftwaffe. Hij zou van 1940(?) -1943 aan het Oostfront hebben gevlogen, daarna zes maanden in Afrika - nog vreemder, want op 13 mei 1943 gaven de laatste Duitse troepen in Afrika zich over. Wat daarna verteld wordt is zo mogelijk nog onwaarschijnlijker.

Het hele verhaal lijkt vooral verzonnen om een partij vervalst Hitler-materiaal en allerhande andere vervalste nazi-militaria te verkopen.

D2. La increíble historia de un piloto alemán. Made in Iquique. 23-08-2005
http://madeiniquique.blogspot.nl/2005/08/la-increble-historia-de-un-piloto.html
Lot 1474. : HITLER ADOLF: (1889-1945) Fuhrer of the Third Reich 1934-45. An original 10.5 x 14 watercolour painting, purported to be. Invaluable.com, 28-03-2015.

https://www.invaluable.com/auction-lot/hitler-adolf:-1889-1945-fuhrer-of-the-third-rei-1474-c-914477ea18


2015 - 'Hitlers' brengen € 391.000 op

Op een veiling van veilinghuis Weidler in Neurenberg (Nürnberg) brengen aan Hitler toegeschreven aquarellen 391.000 euro op. Een werk wordt zelfs voor 100.000 euro verkocht.

De broeders waren investeerders uit China, Brazilië, de Verenigde Arabische Emiraten, Frankrijk en Duitsland. "Diese Sammler sind nicht auf diesen Maler spezialisiert, sondern haben allgemeines Interesse an hochwertiger Kunst", verklaarde veilinghuiswoordvoerdster Kathrin Weidler.

Het is zeer onwaarschijnlijk dat op deze veiling een authentieke Hitler verhandeld werd.

Veilingcatalogus Auktionshaus Weidler, Nürnberg, 18-20 juni 2015.
http://www.auktionshausweidler.de/dl/A1920-Foto_WEB.pdf
100.000 Euro für ein Hitler-Aquarell. Hitler-Bilder Auktion in Mürnberg. Frankfurter Rundschau, 20-06-2015.
http://www.fr.de/kultur/kunst/hitler-bilder-auktion-in-nuernberg-100-000-euro-fuer-ein-hitler-aquarell-a-461438



2015 - 2 'Hitler'-aquarellen en 2 tekeningen in München

Veilinghuis Hermann Historica biedt op veiling 70r, 12 mei 2015, waar ruim 1300 kavels met voornamelijk Nazi-materiaal (al dan niet echt) worden aangeboden, twee overduidelijke valse Hitleraquarellen en twee vermoedelijk door Albert Speer vervalste 'Hitler'-architectuurschetsen aan.

Een van de twee 'Hitlers', Wien - Hoher Markt, 1913. Het andere werk, ongesigneerd en getiteld Weissenkirchen, stamt van Peter Jahn en heeft een Morgenstern-stempel op de achterkant. Zie: 'Het stempel - een nieuwe ontdekking'.


Ook wordt een collectie van ruim 200 door kunstzwendelaar Peter Jahn uitgeschreven 'echtheidscerificaten' bij 'Hitlers' aangeboden. De verwachte opbrengstprijs was 1000 euro - onbekend is voor hoeveel euro deze voor vervalsers zeer aantrekkelijke collectie verkocht is.

Daarnaast biedt Hermann Historica een groot aantal aan Hitler toegeschreven voorwerpen 'uit de collectie Anni Winter' aan, rijkelijk voorzien van 'echtheidsbewijzen'. Zie: Certificates of Authenticity - Anni Winter.



© Compilation Bart FM Droog, 2020.